Amish Country Northern Indiana>

Filter Your Results

Dining

Bring your appetite

Hearty meals of fried chicken and slow-roasted beef with all the trimmings. Homemade noodles and fresh-baked pies. This belt-loosening fare can be found at welcoming diners and popular family-style restaurants where steaming platters and bowls of food are passed around the table. And then there are the cozy cafes, eclectic downtown eateries and locally owned restaurants all popular for delicious signature fare and friendly service. It's all a part of the incredibly diverse menu along the Heritage Trail.

Amish Acres Restaurant Barn

Amish Acres Restaurant Barn

Acclaimed as Indiana's best meal, the family style Thresher's dinner features steaming kettles of bean soup along with platters of chicken, ham and beef and other savory Amish fare.   Desserts include the prized Shoofly pie along with a selection ...more

T: (574) 773-4188 TF: (800) 800-4942  | E: janislogsdon@amishacres.com | W: View Website

Das Dutchman Essenhaus Bakery

Das Dutchman Essenhaus Bakery

Fill your basket with unique made-from-scratch favorites like apple butter or our own delicious noodles. Breads, rolls, cookies and over 30 varieties of pie are available fresh-from-the-oven.

T: (574) 825-9471 TF: (800) 455-9471  | E: info@essenhaus.com | W: View Website

Das Dutchman Essenhaus Restaurant

Das Dutchman Essenhaus Restaurant

Our Amish country kitchen has a table waiting just for you! Authentic family-style dinners are all-you-can-eat complete with beverage and desset or enjoy our NEW lunch and dinner buffets. Buffet Information Family-Style Information Hertiage Hall ...more

T: (574) 825-0052 TF: (800) 455-9471  | E: info@essenhaus.com | W: View Website

Log Cabin Soda Shop & Fudgery at Amish Acres

Log Cabin Soda Shop & Fudgery at Amish Acres

The antique marble soda fountain offers up a variety of delicious treats from sodas, malts, and ice cream to old fashioned fountain drinks and slices of freshly baked pie a la mode. Dozens of flavors of fudge are made daily along with other ...more

T: (574) 773-4188 TF: (800) 800-4942  | E: janislogsdon@amishacres.com | W: View Website

The Blue Gate Restaurant, Bakery & Theater

The Blue Gate Restaurant, Bakery & Theater

When Mel first opened in the mid 80’s the Blue Gate, formerly Der Strudel Haus, had 50 seats and one dining room. Over the years it grew to 105 seats and two dining rooms, but it was never big enough to accommodate the number of people who wanted to ...more

T: (260) 768-4725 TF: (888) 447-4725  | E: bgate@riegsecker.com | W: View Website

Concord Mall

Concord Mall

Official Stop on the Quilt Gardens Along the Heritage Trail. Visit Hobby Lobby and Joann Fabrics – Where You Can Find All Your Quilting & Crafting Supplies and So Much More! Over 60 Stores Fashion, Accessories, Books,Jewelry, Crafts, Cards and ...more

T: 574-875-6502  | W: View Website

b on the River

b on the River

b on the River welcomes you to their cozy cafe and gift store ont eh RiverWalk in Elkhart. Enjoy morning coffee and breakfast by the stone fireplace. Or have a delightful quiche, Panini or salad meal for lunch or dinner.  Sit on the landscaped ...more

T: (574) 293-9333  | E: info@bontheriver.com | W: View Website

Crystal Ballroom Catering

Crystal Ballroom Catering

Great gatherings start with a gorgeous setting. The Crystal Ballroom delivers both. Brand new and beautifully appointed, this one-of-a-kind event space matches the elegance of the historic Lerner Theatre next door. The expansive setting comfortably ...more

| W: View Website

Kelly Jae's Cafe Make a Reservation

Kelly Jae's Cafe

Choose from an eclectic menu of Asian-influenced large and small plates enjoyed in the lovely dining room, the adjacent upscale bar or al fresco. Owner Kelly Jae Graff is recognized as one of Indiana’s top chefs. Her recipes have appeared in Bon App...more

T: 574-537-1027  | E: info@kellyjaescafe.com | W: View Website

McCarthy's on the RiverWalk Make a Reservation

McCarthy's on the RiverWalk

From classic food and drink in its pub-like bar to upscale private dining, McCarthy’s on the RiverWalk offers a range of dining accommodations in a beautiful waterside setting. Enjoy a relaxing lunch on the covered patio or a delicious filet mignon ...more

T: (574) 293-2830  | E: info@McCarthysOnTheRiverwalk.com | W: View Website

Yoder's Meat & Cheese Company

Yoder's Meat & Cheese Company

Only the freshest beef, pork, lamb, poultry and buffalo find their way to Yoder’s. Their top quality grain-fed beef is raised naturally on local farms without growth hormones, steroids or by-products and is dry-aged for maximum tenderness and ...more

T: 260-768-7505  | W: View Website

Venturi

Venturi

Venturi faithfully follows the tradition of Vera Pizza Napoletana.  Crafted with imported Caputo flour, San Marzano tomatoes, fresh basil and mozzarella hand made daily, each pizza is wood fired at 900 degrees for a deliciously distinctive ...more

T: (574) 485-2985  | E: ilcapo@eatventuri.com | W: View Website

Aunt Karen's Cafe

Aunt Karen's Cafe

Signature sandwiches, soups & salads plus pies, muffins, cinnamon rolls & cookies made from scratch. Breakfast & lunch (evening by reservation - groups 10+).

T: (574) 825-1122 

Jojo's Pretzels Goshen

Jojo's Pretzels Goshen

Choose from dozens of delicious soft pretzel possibilities from cinnamon sugar to sour crea and onion.  Always hot, fresh and delicious.

T: (574) 534-5656  | W: View Website

Jojo's Pretzels Shipshewana

Jojo's Pretzels Shipshewana

Choose from dozens of delicious soft pretzel possibilities from cinnamon sugar to sour crea and onion.  Always hot, fresh and delicious.

T: (260) 768-7759  | W: View Website

South Side Soda Shop

South Side Soda Shop

Featured on The Food Network and in Gourmet magazine. In-house bakery, daily specials, fresh seafood, chili, homemade soups, sandwiches & pie.

T: (574) 534-3790  | E: ssss@southsidesodashopdiner.com | W: View Website

Amish Frozen Custard & Soft Serve Ice Cream

Amish Frozen Custard & Soft Serve Ice Cream

Serving rich, creamy frozen custard and famous soft serve ice-cream specialties for over 18 years. Buses and motor coaches welcomed.

T: 260-768-7770  | E: 2008@amish.org | W: View Website

Auction Restaurant

Auction Restaurant

Take a break from Flea Market shopping by sitting down to a delicious Amish meal or a quick sandwich and the best homemade pie in Shipshewana.

T: 260-768-4129  | E: info@tradingplaceamerica.com | W: View Website

Country Corral Restaurant

Country Corral Restaurant

“Cooking like Mom’s.” Sandwiches, homemade soups, salads, pies, daily specials. Breakfast & lunch.

T: 260-768-4589 

Country Lane Bakery

Country Lane Bakery

Made-from-scratch bread, cinnamon rolls, cookies, pies and other delicious goodies! Also offers locally made noodles, apple butter, peach butter and peanut butter spread.

T: (574) 825-7918 

Dutch Kitchen

Dutch Kitchen

Home cooking, daily specials, weekend buffets, generous portions, country setting. Homemade pies, cakes, cinnamon rolls and apple dumplings.

T: (574) 773-2828  | E: millersdutchkitchen@gmail.com | W: View Website

Kukui's Hawaiian Shaved Ice & Eatery

Kukui's Hawaiian Shaved Ice & Eatery

Authentic Hawaiian shave ice, Kalua pulled-pork sandwiches, Hawaiian nachos, all beef hotdogs, pineapple slaw, soups, ice cream, and 100% Kona coffee.

T: (260) 768-4383  | E: cindy@kukuis.com | W: View Website

Next Door Neighbor Deli

Next Door Neighbor Deli

Located on a working farm between Middlebury and Shipshewana. Our full line of pies, cookies, muffins, cinnamon rolls and specialty fruitcakes are baked on site. Bus & RV parking.

T: (574) 825-1716  | W: View Website

Olympia Candy Kitchen Make a Reservation

Olympia Candy Kitchen

Regulars swear by the chocolate malts, hand-dipped candies, and breakfast & lunch specials at this 102-year-old, family-owned soda fountain & shop.

T: 574-533-5040  | E: olympiaskathy@aol.com | W: View Website

Rise 'N Roll Bakery & Deli

Rise 'N Roll Bakery & Deli

Famed for its cinnamon caramel donuts, mouthwatering pastries & crunch candies – cashew, pecan & nutty. Always serving free coffee and fresh samples.

T: 574-825-4032  | W: View Website

The Carriage House

The Carriage House

Come discover our best! Amish family-style meals cooked just for you. Groups of 12-150. Reservations required.

T: 260 768-8199 ext 2128 

The Legendary Grind

The Legendary Grind

Charming café serving homemade soups, signature sandwiches and specialty salads; smoothies; pie & pastries, teas, and signature espresso blends. Breakfast & lunch. 

T: (574) 538-7242  | W: View Website

Village Inn of Middlebury

Village Inn of Middlebury

Amish handmade pies, daily specials, pizza and a whole lot of local charm. Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner.

T: 574-825-2043  | W: View Website

Nearby Destinations

Keep Informed

Sign-up for E-News Today!