Amish Country Northern Indiana
Home > Things To Do > Dining

Filter Your Results

Dining

Bring your appetite

Hearty meals of fried chicken and slow-roasted beef with all the trimmings. Homemade noodles and fresh-baked pies. This belt-loosening fare can be found at welcoming diners and popular family-style restaurants where steaming platters and bowls of food are passed around the table. And then there are the cozy cafes, eclectic downtown eateries and locally owned restaurants all popular for delicious signature fare and friendly service. It's all a part of the incredibly diverse menu along the Heritage Trail.

Amish Acres Restaurant Barn

Amish Acres Restaurant Barn

Acclaimed as Indian's best meal, the family style Thresher's dinner features steaming kettles of bean soup along with platters of chicken, ham and beef and other savory Amish fare. Desserts include the prized Shoofly pie along with a selection of ...more

T: (574) 773-4188 TF: (800) 800-4942  | E: janislogsdon@amishacres.com | W: View Website

Das Dutchman Essenhaus Bakery

Das Dutchman Essenhaus Bakery

Fill your basket with unique made-from-scratch favorites like apple butter or our own delicious noodles. Breads, rolls, cookies and over 30 varieties of pie are available fresh-from-the-oven.

T: (574) 825-9471 TF: (800) 455-9471  | E: info@essenhaus.com | W: View Website

Das Dutchman Essenhaus Restaurant

Das Dutchman Essenhaus Restaurant

Our Amish country kitchen has a table waiting just for you! Authentic family-style dinners are all-you-can-eat complete with beverage and dessert.

T: (574) 825-0052 TF: (800) 455-9471  | E: info@essenhaus.com | W: View Website

Davis Mercantile

Davis Mercantile

The merchants of the Davis Mercantile welcome you. Beneath it's massive timbers, you're sure to collect some unique and interesting finds at more than 23 inviting shops. Throughout the Mercantile, you'll find home accents, apparel, and Amish-inspired ...more

T: 260-768-7300  | W: View Website

Lerner Theatre Make a Reservation

Lerner Theatre

Newly restored and expanded! 1920s-era movie house turned performing arts complex features a 1,700-seat theatre, flexible banquet hall, classroom space, backstage tours and more. In the heart of downtown’s Arts & Entertainment district.

T: (574) 294-4469 TF: (800) 294-8223  | E: info@thelerner.com | W: View Website

Log Cabin Soda Shop & Fudgery at Amish Acres

Log Cabin Soda Shop & Fudgery at Amish Acres

The antique marble soda fountain offers up a variety of delicious treats from sodas, malts, and ice cream to old fashioned fountain drinks and slices of freshly baked pie a la mode. Dozens of flavors of fudge are made daily along with other ...more

T: (574) 773-4188 TF: (800) 800-4942  | E: janislogsdon@amishacres.com | W: View Website

The Blue Gate Restaurant & Theater

The Blue Gate Restaurant & Theater

A complete dining, shopping, and entertainment complex in the heart of Shipshewana. Home to the some of the most unique handcrafted furniture and specialty shops in the area. The Blue Gate Restaurant serves up tasty Amish/Mennonite cooking and quality ...more

T: (260) 768-4725 TF: (888) 447-4725  | E: bgate@riegsecker.com | W: View Website

Mario's

Mario's

As a premier caterer to all of Elkhart, Mishawaka, South Bend, Granger, Osceola and surrounding communities, Mario's Catering believes in freshness and quality. We are dedicated to giving you the best possible quality and service. At Mario's Catering ...more

T: 574-293-7069 

Nelson's Banquet Hall

Nelson's Banquet Hall

From twenty-five to 25,000, no party is too big or small for Nelson's. Offering a full menu of entrees and side items, our experienced staff can put together a menu to suit your taste and your budget. Whether it's chicken and ribs, or hamburgers and ...more

T: 574-862-2184 TF: 800-224-3435  | E: jasonhertell@nelsonsbbq.com | W: View Website

The Blue Gate Restaurant

The Blue Gate Restaurant

When the Blue Gate opened in 1986 it had only 50 seats, but after 15 years the little restaurant had become so popular because of its great food and service it could have up to a 2-hour wait. It was then the Riegsecker Family decided to build the new ...more

T: (260) 768-4725 TF: (888) 447-4725  | W: View Website

Concord Mall

Concord Mall

Over 60 stores, many which are America's greatest retail brands. The Grove Food Court features plasma TV's and a fireplace. Coupons and gift cards available. 2012 Quilt Gardens mural location featuring Jazz It Up and the . At the Concord Mall you can ...more

T: 574-875-6502  | W: View Website

DaVinci's Italian Family Rest. Make a Reservation

DaVinci's Italian Family Rest.

Family-owned, authentic Italian cuisine. Great pizza, sandwiches, salads, pasta, steaks, seafood, beer, wine & cocktails.

T: 574-264-6248  | E: davincisrestaurant@gmail.com | W: View Website

b on the River

b on the River

Cozy cafe and gift store in a charming, riverfront setting. Home accents, jewelry, cards and custom artwork perfect for all occasions and wedding registry.

T: 574-293-9333  | E: info@bontheriver.com | W: View Website

Crystal Ballroom Catering

Crystal Ballroom Catering

Great gatherings start with a gorgeous setting. The Crystal Ballroom delivers both. Brand new and beautifully appointed, this one-of-a-kind event space matches the elegance of the historic Lerner Theatre next door. The expansive setting comfortably ...more

T: (574) 293-1755  | E: nicole@crystalballroomcatering.com | W: View Website

Kelly Jae's Cafe Make a Reservation

Kelly Jae's Cafe

Exceptional and creative food in a casual, hip setting. Located in the heart of downtown Goshen’s historic shopping district, Kelly Jae’s offers an eclectic menu of tapas-style dining with an Asian flair. Chef/Owner Kelly Jae Graff has been ...more

T: 574-537-1027  | E: info@kellyjaescafe.com | W: View Website

McCarthy's on the RiverWalk Make a Reservation

McCarthy's on the RiverWalk

Lunch and dinner are served overlooking the Elkhart River at this downtown restaurant with a family friendly pub atmosphere. The inventive and affordable menu includes appetizers, a range of sandwiches and Irish classics such as corned beef and ...more

T: 574-293-2830  | E: info@McCarthysOnTheRiverwalk.com | W: View Website

Yoder's Meat & Cheese Company

Yoder's Meat & Cheese Company

Only the freshest beef, pork, lamb, poultry and buffalo find their way to Yoder’s. Their top quality grain-fed beef is raised naturally on local farms without growth hormones, steroids or by-products and is dry-aged for maximum tenderness and ...more

T: 260-768-7505  | W: View Website

Venturi

Venturi

Wood-fired pizza prepared in the Neapolitan tradition features rich, authentic flavors and the freshest ingredients. All dishes prepared with the freshest ingredients including house-made pesto and mozzarella. The menu includes seasonal salads, ...more

T: (574) 485-2985  | E: ilcapo@eatventuri.com | W: View Website

Aunt Karen's Cafe

Aunt Karen's Cafe

Signature sandwiches, soups & salads plus pies, muffins, cinnamon rolls & cookies made from scratch. Breakfast & lunch (evening by reservation - groups 10+).

T: (574) 825-1122 

Culver's of Elkhart

Culver's of Elkhart

Savor the signature ButterBurger® made from fresh - never frozen - 100% US raised beef. Palate-pleasing salads, savory sandwiches, scrumptious homestyle dinners and frozen custard. Buses/RVs welcome. 4 blocks west of SR 19/Cassopolis St (next to ...more

T: (574) 266-8610  | W: View Website

Grandma's Pantry

Grandma's Pantry

Oven fresh breads, donuts & cookies baked on site daily; full deli with 50 varieties of cheese, smoked meats & specialty salads; large selection of spices, grains, candy & produce. Bulk prices – all sizes!

T: (574) 862-1959 

M&L Acres

M&L Acres

Melvin & LeAnna Yoder welcome you with home cooked and hearty Amish favorites – chicken, beef, made-from-scratch breads & pies. Lunch & dinner; Haystack breakfast. Family-style. Individuals or groups up to 80.

T: (260) 768-3248 

Mattern's Butcher Shop & Corner Deli Make a Reservation

Mattern's Butcher Shop & Corner Deli

Third generation local butcher shop with a dine-in delicatessen offering all natural-fed veal, lamb, beef, pork, chicken and fresh wild caught seafood with no supplemented growth hormones, added steroids or by-products. Premium deli meats and artisan ...more

T: (574) 971-8906  | E: info@matternsmeatsanddeli.com | W: View Website

Miller's Country Kitchen

Miller's Country Kitchen

Fresh and flavorful best describe the hearty meals served in this charming Amish home. The Farmer’s Breakfast, Thrasher’s Meal and Wedding Dinner are favorites. Groups of 10 – 150. Reservations required.

T: 574-825-3314  | W: View Website

Stone Soup Emporium / Bonnie & Clyde's Soda Shop

Stone Soup Emporium / Bonnie & Clyde's Soda Shop

Features art, gifts, antiques, vintage ice cream treats and homemade soups and sandwiches. A short drive down the road. A long walk down memory lane...

T: (574) 848-4761  | E: bcss.sodashop@gmail.com | W: View Website

Sweet Creams Soda Shop

Sweet Creams Soda Shop

Enjoy old fashioned ice cream delights, gourmet sandwiches, soups, art & conversation in a century old building. Live music on Friday and Saturday evenings.

T: 574-970-5568 

The Marketplace of Middlebury Make a Reservation

The Marketplace of Middlebury

Two floors of antiques, collectibles, primitives, furniture and home accents plus locally-produced jams, jellies and chocolates. On site café.

T: 574-825-4001  | W: View Website

Amish Frozen Custard & Soft Serve Ice Cream

Amish Frozen Custard & Soft Serve Ice Cream

Serving rich, creamy frozen custard and famous soft serve ice-cream specialties for over 18 years. Buses and motor coaches welcomed.

T: 260-768-7770  | E: 2008@amish.org | W: View Website

Auction Restaurant

Auction Restaurant

While shopping at the Flea Market, take time to sit down for a delicious Amish-style meal or a quick sandwich.

T: 260-768-4129  | E: info@tradingplaceamerica.com | W: View Website

Buggy Lane Tours, LLC

Buggy Lane Tours, LLC

Customized van and bus groups and backroad Amish country tours! German/English speaking step-on guides, delicious Amish home meals, buggy rides.Visit schools, buggy and furniture shops. Group rates.

T: 574-238-4498  | E: kenny@buggylanetours.com | W: View Website

Country Corral Restaurant

Country Corral Restaurant

“Cooking like Mom’s.” Sandwiches, homemade soups, salads, pies, daily specials. Breakfast & lunch.

T: 260-768-4589 

Country Lane Bakery

Country Lane Bakery

Made-from-scratch bread, cinnamon rolls, cookies, pies and other delicious goodies! Also offers locally made noodles, apple butter, peach butter and peanut butter spread.

T: 574-825-7918 

Dutch Maid Bakery

Dutch Maid Bakery

Since 1942. Large assortment of pastries, cakes and cookies. Soups, salads, sandwiches, espresso. Relaxing setting. Free WiFi.

T: 574-533-1940  | W: View Website

Kukui's Hawaiian Shaved Ice & Eatery

Kukui's Hawaiian Shaved Ice & Eatery

Authentic Hawaiian shaved ice (30 flavors), pulled-pork sandwiches, sausages & hotdogs with tropical mustards & relishes, nachos & cheese, ice cream & real Kona coffee.

T: 574-536-8463 

Laura's Country Store

Laura's Country Store

Browse through 150 handmade quilts, locally crafted gift items and furniture. Enjoy a sweet roll & coffee from our bakery or a sandwich from our deli.

T: (260) 562-2800 

Miller's Dutch Kitchen

Miller's Dutch Kitchen

Home cooking, daily specials, weekend buffets, generous portions, country setting. Homemade pies, cakes, cinnamon rolls and apple dumplings.

T: 574-773-2828  | E: millersdutchkitchen@gmail.com | W: View Website

Next Door Neighbor Deli

Next Door Neighbor Deli

Located on a working farm between Middlebury and Shipshewana. Our full line of pies, cookies, muffins, cinnamon rolls and specialty fruitcakes are baked on site.

T: 574-825-1716  | W: View Website

Olympia Candy Kitchen Make a Reservation

Olympia Candy Kitchen

Regulars swear by the chocolate malts, hand-dipped candies, and breakfast & lunch specials at this 100-year-old, family-owned soda fountain & shop.

T: 574-533-5040  | E: olympiaskathy@aol.com | W: View Website

Rise 'N Roll Bakery & Deli

Rise 'N Roll Bakery & Deli

Famed for its cinnamon caramel donuts, mouthwatering pastries & crunch candies – cashew, pecan & nutty. Always serving free coffee and fresh samples.

T: 574-825-4032  | W: View Website

South Side Soda Shop

South Side Soda Shop

Featured on The Food Network and in Gourmet magazine. In-house bakery, daily specials, fresh seafood, chili, homemade soups, sandwiches & pie.

T: 574-534-3790  | E: ssss@southsidesodashopdiner.com | W: View Website

The Carriage House

The Carriage House

Relax and savor satisfying Amish family style meals created by a mother-son team. Groups of 12-150. Reservations required.

T: 260 768-8199 ext 2128 

The Legendary Grind

The Legendary Grind

Charming café serving homemade soups, signature sandwiches and specialty salads; smoothies; pie & pastries, teas, coffees and lattes. Breakfast & lunch.

T: (574) 538-7242 

Village Inn of Middlebury

Village Inn of Middlebury

Amish handmade pies, daily specials, pizza and a whole lot of local charm. Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner.

T: 574-825-2043 

Nearby Destinations

Keep Informed

Sign-up for E-News Today!