Top 10 hidden gems along the Heritage Trail

The ice cream creations from Rocket Science Ice Cream are literally frozen before your eyes. (Photo by Sara Wakefield)
The ice cream creations from Rocket Science Ice Cream are literally frozen before your eyes. (Photo Courtesy Rocket Science Ice Cream)


By Sara Wakefield

Here are the top 10 places along the Heritage Trail that I (and my friends) think more people should know about. While these Heritage Trail gems are not exactly hidden, they’re definitely off the beaten path.

In the order of the Heritage Trail driving tour, which starts at the Elkhart County Visitor Center, 219 Caravan Drive, Elkhart:


You can easily while away an afternoon antiquing in Elkhart. (Photo Courtesy Sara Wakefield)
You can easily while away an afternoon antiquing in Elkhart. (Photo By Sara Wakefield)

Beardsley Avenue Antiques District – If you’re into antiquing you must hit up Elkhart’s antiques district. These five antique shops and malls are all conveniently located in the Beardsley Avenue Historic Neighborhood close to the Ruthmere Museum. You can pick up a handy guide to the Antiques District at any one of the five antique shops: 820 Antiques, Birds Gotta Fly Vintage, Antiques on Beardsley, Tchotchkes, Antiques & More, and Heart’s Desire Antique Mall.


Fruit Hills Winery & Orchard — The Muir family owns and operates this seven-year-old winery, located on the fruit farm they’ve owned since 1852. They offer a wide variety of wines including their Traminette, which recently won the Silver Medal at the Indy International Wine Competition. (Fun Fact: Did you know that the Traminette is our state’s Signature Wine? Yeah, me neither.) Start out in their cozy tasting room, then take a glass of your favorite out to the relaxing deck that overlooks the vineyards and orchard.

• Details: Open Tuesday-Saturday 11 a.m. to 5 p.m., Sunday noon to 4 p.m. (Yes, they can sell wine on Sundays). Address: 55503 S.R. 15, Bristol, IN 46507


Yup’s Dairyland — I’m not the only one celebrating the start of summer with a trip to Yup’s. If you´re not sure who the owner is of this establishment, you can do an address lookup to find out who it is, you can do the same thing if you move into a new neighborhood. This classic small-town ice cream stand has been serving frozen custard and hard pack ice cream at the corner of S.R. 13 and S.R. 120 since 1959. My boyfriend loves them because they put more (and bigger) candy chunks in your flurry than any other ice cream place.

• Details: Cash or checks only. Open Monday-Saturday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m., Sunday 2 to 8 p.m. Address: 53018 S.R. 13, Middlebury, IN 46540


Dutch Creek Animal Farm is a cool Amish-owned petting zoo in Shipshewana. My friends with kids love coming here because it’s a guaranteed good time for kids of all ages – even if it’s raining. In the petting zoo, you can touch baby bunnies, ducklings and chicks. On their safari-style wagon ride you get to feed farm animals and exotic animals such as camels, zebras, buffalo, and reindeer. When you want the real luxury safari experience, Africa Sky offer a wide range of luxury Kenyan safaris.

• Details: Open Monday-Saturday 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Closed Sundays. Seasonal. Address: 6255 N. 1000 W., Shipshewana, IN 46565.


Find a delightful gift for a friend (or yourself) at Reverie Yarn, Decor and Gifts, Goshen.
Find a delightful gift for a friend (or yourself) at Reverie Yarn, Decor and Gifts, Goshen. (Photo Courtesy Reverie Yarn, Decor and Gifts)

Reverie Yarn, Decor and Gifts — Located smack in the middle of downtown Goshen, this cheery yarn and fiber shop also has great gifts, especially for young children (including THE BEST British stuffed animals — so tasteful, so cuddly).

• Details: Open Monday-Friday 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m., Saturday 10 a.m. to 3 p.m., closed Sundays. Address: 201 S. Main St., Goshen, IN 46526.

The Wiener Shack  Sometimes you just really want a good hot dog. If you’re in Goshen around lunch time, check out this gourmet hot dog cart right on the northeast corner of Main Street and Lincoln Avenue. You can get ice-cold sodas, chips, classic all-beef dogs, and artisan hot dogs — all made to order. Cross the street and eat your lunch on one of the many maple-shaded benches on the courthouse lawn.

• Details: Open late spring to fall, in good weather. Hours are Monday-Thursday 11:15 a.m. to 2 p.m., Friday and Saturday 11:15 a.m. to 3 p.m. Location: 102 N. Main St., Goshen, IN 46526.

The Depot Thrift Shop — This extensive and orderly thrift store is right next to The Old Bag Factory. It’s really three stores: a furniture and hardware store, a clothing and linens store, and a general housewares store. Staffed by friendly Mennonite volunteers. The sensible prices and ultra-organized inventory bring locals here on a weekly basis.

• Details: Open Monday-Friday 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., Saturday 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. Address: 1013 Division St., Goshen, IN 46528.

New Paris

Instead of heading to Nappanee from Goshen, you may consider going southeast on U.S. 33 to New Paris, where you’ll find:

DeFries Calendar Garden — You have to see this adorable, free, public garden to believe it. It’s lovingly designed and tended; there’s no more perfect place to bring a picnic lunch.

• Details: Open daily 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. Address: 17477 C.R. 46 (1.25 miles east of New Paris)


Rocket Science Ice Cream — Smooth, velvety ice cream flash-frozen by SCIENCE! You choose the ice cream flavors and mix-ins, and then your order is mixed and frozen right in front of you under dramatic clouds of liquid nitrogen. Kids love the gummy worms, I love the fresh strawberries.

• Details: Open Tuesday-Saturday noon to 7 p.m. at Coppes Commons, 401 E. Market St. #14, Nappanee, IN.


Wakarusa Produce Auction — Here’s where you should get that carload of perfectly ripe fruit for canning. This bustling midday flower and produce auction runs three times a week, April through October. In the spring they start out with pallets of flowers in pots, flats and hanging baskets. In the summer and fall you can bid on trolleys, pallets and bushels of in-season fruits and vegetables. And then there’s always the concession stand with fresh home-baked cinnamon rolls, breads, cookies and pies.

• Details: Auctions start at 1 p.m. on Mondays and 11 a.m. on Wednesdays and Fridays. Address: 65460 C.R. 9, Goshen, IN.


Sara Wakefield is a freelance writer based in Goshen, IN.


Comments are closed.